East PErth Train Station

p2200789.jpgp2250016.jpgp2250019.jpgp2250020.jpgp2250022.jpgp2250025.jpgp2250027.jpgp2250030.jpgp2250031.jpgp2250033.jpg

This is, in my opinion, the best example of commercial large scale architecture in WA. Its a big call, but its a big building. It is also one of the most polarising buildings here, you either adore it, or hate it worse than cancer.  If your cool, you fall into the former. This is one of those buildings that proudly put our architecture at the forefront of an international movement. It is an original, and peculiarly West Australian structure, that sets it apart from a lot of our canonised architecture. For example, whlie we produced a lot of great modernism, it was universal throughout the world, and ours wasnt particularly ground breaking( there are cases for it, but excuse the blatant and dumb sidestepping) this example, brutalism of the highest order, was not an entirely universal concept, and WA was one place that jumped upon it in its infancy. And the brutalism we produced is of the very highest order. It is unfortunately a style that operates outside the popular permaters of good taste and acceptability. Tony Brand is one of the most important architects the state has seen pass through it, yet he is constantly on the periphery of vision. Anyways, enough incoherent ramble, this building is soo good. It looks like an aircraft carrier. Thank god it was heritage listed. if this got knocked down, i would kill myself. or at least move to Chandigarh.

5 Responses to “East PErth Train Station”

  1. Susie spendy Says:

    the worm holes are brilliant

  2. lisa Says:

    The worm holes always remind me of the pompidou centre.
    http://www.centrepompidou.fr/informations/pratique/architecture/archi07.html
    Your photos are fantastic.

  3. archiearchive FCD Says:

    I have just discovered your site - through “Perth’s Worst”.

    I’m impressed with much of what you have done yet I must must MUST disagree with you on this one.

    East Perth Railway Station, while it has its good points on the inside, has to be the single most ugly public building in Perth when viewed from the outside! It is even worse than the House of a Thousand Bathtubs on the corner of St Geo Tce and Vic Ave! It has no aesthetic qualities, it makes no pretence of fitting with the environment, it stands like a monolithic Jabba The Hutt, dominating its surroundings (and there are some beautiful surrounding buildings) with its unfeeling brutality!

  4. Ollie Lindsell Says:

    archiearchive FCD [it makes no pretence of fitting with the environment,] WHat environment do you anticipate it is supposed to fit into? THe freeway or the cement works further up? As you approach it along the Graham Farmer it appears as if it is a sea liner about to sail off, or an aircraft carrier as mentioned, which is totally ‘fitting’ given its function as a travel terminus. I love how it provides different devices to shade its windows from the sun. Look again I say.

  5. joeb Says:

    I feel the building engages quite beautifully with the environment. It’s a wonderful study of human scale design repeated and arrayed. Each facade studies a single window and how it should be welcome or block the sun and is then repeated across the height and breadth of the facade resulting in a wonderful texture that speaks as much about the massive city scale as it does for the individual behind a single window. The result is a different treatment to each facade, as it should be. Then the real wonder in the building is the revealed as you move past it and and each face shifts and changes. Or if you stand and watch it - as the sun moves.
    While in the Brutalist style it’s wonderfully considered and has a beauty that is both delicate and confronting at the same time.

    to say it doesn’t fit into it’s environment would be akin to deriding Urulu for spoiling the desert.

Leave a Reply